Alison’s tomato pie

This is not like any tomato pie or tart I’ve ever made but since Alison Roman told me it was the best she’d ever eaten I sorta believed her.

Alison Roman eating spaghetti

I actually pay for her e-newsletter and subscribe to her channel. Not that I agree with her on all things, she eats whole anchovies, fer chrissake. She is also waaaay to free with the garlic. While we have food related philosophical differences, I like her, she’s fun and funny, and I enjoy her thoughts on food and food preparation even if I disagree with her on some stuff. It’s not like a we’re-gonna-get-in-a-fist-fight kinda difference. But for instance, she loves kale. Ugh. Nevertheless, I still wanna hear what she has to say about it. I also want to be in her circle of friends (except if she’s eating anchovies out of the can or kale chips). Over all, I mostly like what she says and so, decided to make her tomato tart, watch the video here. Or if you only want the recipe, you can see it here.

This is not like the tomato tart I normally make with mustard, cheese and tomatoes in a standard pie crust. It has a parmesan-cheesy cornmeal crust that you sort of mush into the tart pan like play-doh and pre-bake. The filling is all tomatoes (plus capers and too much garlic). I used heirloom tomatoes I’d bought at the farmer’s market. I worried that the crust would just get soggy.

But I followed the recipe exactly (so not me). And she was right about that. It really is great. But she was wrong in the video when she says it’s great the next day. It’s not. It needs to get eaten the same day. She probably never has eaten it the next day because whatever food she makes is eaten by the swarms of people who are constantly surrounding her. (Unfortunately none of them are me.) There are never leftovers.

The next day the crust was soggy. Like breakfast-oatmeal-level soggy. Still good but not quite what you to want to serve to the Maharani of Cooch-Behar.

6 Replies to “Alison’s tomato pie”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *