Guess which ones were Pick N Save and which were off the Georgia Peach Truck.
If you picked the lovely juicy pink peaches on the left as off the peach truck you’d be wrong. I made a delicious peach pie with peaches from Pick N Save and then, days later seeing the peach truck at the farmer’s market bought another load for what I thought would be the peach pie of my life.
In one sense it was, the worst one. The peaches were fibrous, tasteless and turned gray as soon as they were peeled. Actually, I didn’t make a pie with them, I threw them out, a detritus pie. I rushed back to Pick N Save and bought nectarines and made a glorious tart.
Unfortunately didn’t get a pic of it. You’ll have to trust me on that.



I had a similar experience earlier this summer with peaches from the peach truck. They were terrible but I made a peach pie, too. I had to throw it out. My mistake was compounded by making Nora Ephron’s famous peach pie which called for three peaches . Three. I used seven.
The custard base never set (probably because I didn’t follow the recipe) but it still would have been tasteless. Now I’ve been feasting on peaches from the grocery store which are ripening one at a time and each has been the real deal.
However, I must comment on your food stylist. Those poor farmer’s market peaches are not shown at their best, browning on a white plate against the butcher block background. Also lurking back there are some overripe bananas. The “good” peaches are artfully displayed like a Cezanne painting with a gleaming bowl in the background and the peaches displayed on a golden-yellow sheet. A person wants to snatch one up and drip the juices off the chin.
Food styling aside, in the end your argument holds up well: don’t fall for a Georgia peach.
The good peaches are sitting on a plastic cutting board and the bad peaches are positioned in a gleaming white bowl on a charming wooden cutting board. It’s a ll in the phrasing.